• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About
    • Contact
  • Blog
  • Faith
    • Kids in the Word
  • Motherhood
    • Depression
    • Recipes
  • Homeschooling
    • Printables
    • Curriculum
    • History
    • Math
    • Science

The Pelsers

A Shelter for the Heart

By Tasha Via

5 Questions To Ask Yourself Before Giving Consequences

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my full disclosure statement here.
Pin2K
Share46
Tweet5
2K Shares

disciplineI am the worst at spurting off a consequence for a particular offense before thinking all the way through it.

For example, yesterday my highly emotional 8-year-old was having a very anxious morning. I mean a R-E-A-L-L-Y tough morning.

At some point during the morning he had gained full control over the step-stool from the kitchen and was carrying it around so nobody else could use it. Not that anybody else truly NEEDED to use it, but seeing as it was deemed “untouchable” by all but said 8-year-old, the war was on!

Enter mom.

Side note: I have been praying for creative parenting over the past week. I have been working on letting natural consequences take the lead of sinful behavior and on consequences that actually relate to the unacceptable behavior.

So the perfect consequence for this silly little act of rebellion, which was covered in greed, selfishness, and immaturity, was to make him carry the stool around the rest of the morning. He would have to take it to the closet with him to put on his clothes. He would have to sit on it to eat his breakfast and to put his shoes on. He would be “one with the stool” until he walked out the door for school.

As you can imagine, he wasn't too thrilled with his consequence.

He began having an honest-to-goodness panic attack. He began writhing as if he were in pain, then he took off out the door and began thrashing around outside. Lots of screaming and crying continued over the next 20 minutes.

Was the consequence unrealistic?
Absolutely not.

Was the consequence unrelated?
Absolutely not.

Was the consequence the best type of consequence for this particular son at this particular moment?
No.

What I did do was to hand out an appropriate consequence at an inappropriate time.

I didn't take into consideration his emotional state before handing out his consequence. But in my mind, he was being irrational, resulting in inappropriate behavior. So when he acted out in this completely normal 8-year-old boy way I responded with a consequence for a completely normal 8-year-old boy, instead of looking at the full picture. This particular morning was not the time to give this kind of consequence to this particular child.

So how can we reach the heart of our children in creative and fresh ways while still taking into consideration the child and his or her personality?

Here are 5 questions to ask yourself when determining a consequence

1 – What is the offense? Think about the heart behind the action. Was it an immature act of childishness or an act of defiance?

2 – Is this consequence age and child appropriate? Each child is different and will interpret discipline and consequences in different ways. For example, we have a different way of disciplining our adoptive child than our biological children, based on her past and background.

3 – What is the mental and emotional state at the particular time of offense? Are they already on the threshold of an emotional breakdown or tired from a super late night? Take this into consideration.

4 – Is this something that I am willing to be firm and consistent on? Make sure this is a battle worth fighting. If you aren't willing to give it your all, you should go a different route.

5 – Is this a consequence made in a battle of wills hoping to come out on top as the victor, or to mold the heart of your child? I am constantly having to check myself in this area. Is this simply a battle of wills between the mama and the 4-year-old or is it a tactic to help shepherd the heart and character of the child?

Pin2K
Share46
Tweet5
2K Shares

Filed Under: Kids in the Word

About Tasha Via

I'm a mom of 5. I take pride in finally figuring out a good routine to this new "normal", but then the kids wake up and reality really begins!
I am madly in love with the worship pastor at my church and proudly call him my baby's daddy.
I am learning to become still in this life so addicted to instant gratification.
I am still becoming who God is calling me to be...
I Like:
cleaning and organizing the house, rearranging furniture to confuse my family,
sneaking cuddles from my boys, trying to fix the girls hair without a fight,
eating butterfingers, and blogging about the family at www.tashavia.com

Primary Sidebar

Welcome to The Pelsers!

My name is Amanda and this is my family, The Pelsers. Here you'll find a shelter for your heart in the midst of the busy and the chaos with stories about faith, motherhood, and homeschooling. Make yourself at home, take part in the conversation, and enjoy the journey!
Read more about The Pelsers...
The Pelsers in Facebook Amanda Pelser on Twitter Follow Amanda on Pinterest Amanda Pelser on Instagram
How We Saved $7,000 per Year on Health Insurance | ThePelsers.com

Footer

  • Privacy Policy
  • PR & Sponsors
  • Contact

© Copyright 2016 The Pelsers - Amanda Pelser · All Rights Reserved ·
Designed by The Multi-Taskin Mom and The Pelsers Media

Copyright© 2025 · Brunch Pro Theme by Shay Bocks